Social media has overtaken traditional media as a source of relevance and influence for younger audiences, according to Deloitte’s 2025 Digital Media Trends survey. The report finds that 56% of Gen Z say social media content is more relevant to them than traditional TV and movies, while 43% of millennials say the same. The report also finds that 63% of Gen Z and 49% of millennials say social media ads and product reviews influence their purchasing decisions more than traditional paid advertising.
These trends reflect how audiences increasingly rely on social platforms and creator content for discovery and purchase decisions, making social media ads and influencer partnerships among the most culturally relevant ways for brands to reach consumers.
Influencers and content creators weave products and services into everyday digital experiences, presenting them through authentic voices and real personalities. This approach represents a significant evolution in branded storytelling, moving far beyond traditional advertising that relies on actors and scripted commercials.
And yet, just like viewers fast-forwarding through TV commercials, social media audiences often scroll past paid ads without engaging with them. Audiences have learned to tune out anything that feels like an interruption; as a result, in-feed paid influencer partnerships often perform worse than organic creator content, sometimes significantly worse.
This is not a failure of the influencer, the brand, or the platform. It is the result of human behavior, platform dynamics, and regulatory requirements that fundamentally change how content is perceived and distributed once money is involved.
Understanding why this happens and how to plan for it strategically is essential for brands seeking to use influencer marketing effectively.
The Psychology of “Paid Partnership” Fatigue
The moment an audience sees “paid partnership,” “#ad,” or “thanks to [brand],” engagement typically declines. This mirrors how people respond to advertising everywhere else: we skip commercials, scroll past sponsored posts, and mentally disengage when we recognize sales tactics.
Sponsored posts can disrupt the natural “scrolling mode” users enter on social media apps, not necessarily provoking dislike but interrupting cognitive flow in a way that lowers engagement and interest (National Library of Medicine). Even when viewers trust the creator, the paid label itself signals marketing intent, triggering skepticism and reduced attention.
This doesn’t mean influencer marketing doesn’t work. In fact, brands earn an average of $5.78 in revenue for every $1 spent on influencer marketing, outperforming many traditional digital advertising channels. But it does mean performance expectations must be adjusted, and especially once content becomes overtly promotional.
Influencer Marketing Is Not Meant to Behave Like Organic Content
One of the most common mistakes brands make is benchmarking paid influencer posts against the influencer’s organic content when deciding whom to work with. These comparisons are misleading.
Organic content benefits from platform algorithms that favor non-commercial posts, storytelling that flows naturally without creative limitations, and higher audience trust. Psychologically, people are more likely to engage with content they perceive as authentic, which increases saves, shares, and comments. This, in turn, signals the algorithm to distribute the content more widely, including to broader audiences and “For You Pages.”
Paid partnership content, by contrast, faces several obstacles: immediate audience filtering, reduced algorithmic prioritization, and greater viewer scrutiny. As a result, paid posts rarely outperform organic content. And that is okay. However, leaving it at that is not sufficient for a successful, effective social media influencer campaign.
Brands need to take additional steps to ensure the campaign achieves meaningful reach, engagement, and ROI. Without strategic planning and amplification, campaigns risk underperformance, which hurts both the creator and the brand.
What Actually Improves Performance
Paid amplification is an essential element of influencer campaign performance. Whitelisting, which boosts a post using advertising funds directly from the creator’s feed, is critical. This approach ensures sponsored content reaches both the influencer’s existing audience and wider potential audiences. When content is only dark posted and immediately after the in-feed post goes live, their followers may see the ad first rather than the organic post, further reducing engagement on the influencer’s platform.
A budget for boosting is therefore necessary if measurable reach and impact are goals.
Creative strategy matters as much as distribution. But often brands suffocate creativity with over-commercialized requirements, forcing too much advertising language on creators, which leads viewers to scroll past these ads. Posts that lead with a story rather than a product are more engaging because audiences connect with narratives that reflect real-life experiences.
Collaborative posting between the creator and the brand, especially when the brand’s account has a healthy, engaged following, further maintains social proof and preserves the context in which the creator’s audience already interacts.
Thoughtful planning of timelines and creative briefs is also crucial. Allowing sufficient lead time enables creators to produce higher-quality storytelling that resonates with their audience. A rushed turnaround or an overly restrictive brief is not only unprofessional but also detrimental to campaign performance.
Finally, long-term partnerships allow creators to understand the brand more deeply, refine their storytelling, and strengthen audience trust in the recommendations. When brands treat influencer marketing as an ongoing channel rather than a one-time campaign, performance can improve because audiences perceive the content as consistent, relevant, and trustworthy.
Long-term relationships also streamline future collaborations by establishing a shared understanding of workflows, contracts, and rates, which typically require upfront time for each new partnership.
Leave a Reply